We wish we could fit every pacifier and stuffed animal pacifier, unfortunately we can't. Please be mindful to check the brands and photos for assurance that you have a compatible pacifier and pacifier with stuffed animal. If you find you made a mistake after receiving it, we encourage you to donate it to a local NICU or PICU.

Pacifiers with animals

  • WubbaNub®
  • Dr. Browns® Lovey with tab, not loop
  • NUBY® Snuggleez
  • Avent® Soothie Snuggle
  • Ali+Oli Plush
Pacifiers without animals
  • Ali+Oli Modern
  • BIBS® by Mushie
  • Itzy Ritzy
  • Natursutten®
  • NICU Philips Avent® Soothie 
  • NUBY® Cherry Baglet
  • Philips Avent® Soothie 0-3 months and 3+ months

The Keepsie™ is not produced by, affiliated with, or endorsed by any of the compatible pacifiers including Trebco Specialty Products, Inc., the maker of the WUBBANUB plush with pacifier product. WUBBANUB is a registered trademark of Trebco Specialty Products, Inc.